home *** CD-ROM | disk | FTP | other *** search
- <text id=93TT1254>
- <title>
- Mar. 22, 1993: Barbarians on the Screen
- </title>
- <history>
- TIME--The Weekly Newsmagazine--1993
- Mar. 22, 1993 Can Animals Think
- </history>
- <article>
- <source>Time Magazine</source>
- <hdr>
- TELEVISION, Page 66
- Barbarians on the Screen
- </hdr>
- <body>
- <p>A high-finance best seller comes to the tube with the greed
- and nastiness intact, and much of the drama too
- </p>
- <p>By JOE QUEENAN
- </p>
- <p> In the service of truth and beauty, mankind has attempted
- many seemingly impossible tasks down through the ages.
- Michelangelo transformed a bare ceiling into one of the most
- beautiful paintings in the world. Pablo Picasso fashioned a
- stunning work of art out of a pair of abandoned bicycle
- handlebars, and Marcel Duchamp achieved similar wonders with a
- cast-off urinal. Now the folks at Home Box Office have topped
- them all by making a reasonably watchable movie out of a book
- about a leveraged buyout: Barbarians at the Gate, which will
- receive its first showing on HBO this Saturday.
- </p>
- <p> It helped that HBO had a very good book (the 1990 best
- seller Barbarians at the Gate, by Wall Street Journal reporters
- Bryan Burrough and John Helyar) and a very big leveraged buyout
- (Kohlberg Kravis Roberts' epic $25 billion takeover of RJR
- Nabisco in 1988) to work with. And the $7 million HBO earmarked
- for the project probably came in handy too. The film remains
- reasonably faithful to the spirit of the book, while vastly
- simplifying the plot. Whereas Burrough and Helyar recount a
- story that involves dozens of rapacious financiers, greedy
- executives, odious publicists, duplicitous bankers and devious
- attorneys, hbo has boiled down the cast of characters to only
- about a dozen. But they're all pretty avaricious, devious,
- duplicitous or odious, so very little has been lost in
- translation.
- </p>
- <p> To refresh all our memories, let's recall that the whole
- RJR fiasco got started when a hard-drinking, cigar-smoking,
- foul-mouthed Canadian expatriate named F. Ross Johnson, who for
- some inexplicable reason found himself running the 19th largest
- industrial company in the U.S., decided to take the food and
- tobacco colossus private in a leveraged buyout.
- </p>
- <p> In this effort Johnson and six cronies combined forces
- with James Robinson III, the well-liked but not especially
- effective CEO of American Express, and Peter Cohen, the
- not-so-well-liked and not-at-all-effective chairman and CEO of
- Amex's subsidiary, Shearson Lehman Hutton. The triumvirate
- offered stockholders a bid of $75 a share, which added up to
- billions less than RJR was worth, making it quite a steal.
- Worse, the deal left Johnson in control and allowed him a
- package under which he and his pals could haul in as much as
- $2.5 billion. Yes, billion.
- </p>
- <p> Johnson's brazen attempt at highway robbery attracted the
- attention of Henry Kravis, the pixieish juggernaut from KKR, the
- New York City firm that had written the book on leveraged
- buyouts. Kravis, who months earlier had met with Johnson and
- discussed the possibility of taking RJR Nabisco private, was
- furious at Johnson for his double-dealing. With his cousin, and
- KKR partner, George Roberts, Kravis submitted a
- blow-them-out-of-the-water bid of $90 a share.
- </p>
- <p> Kravis' entry in turn aroused the interest of one after
- another of the wheelers and dealers of Wall Street, all avid for
- a piece of the action. After numerous bids, counterbids, leaks,
- secret phone calls, threats, pizzas, lies, midnight meetings,
- attempted bribes, snide remarks about cigarette smoke, and stabs
- in the back, Kravis landed the company for $7.4 billion more
- than Johnson had initially offered, and Johnson got to open a
- $53 million golden parachute and take a hike.
- </p>
- <p> By the time Columbia Pictures started thinking about
- filming Barbarians, whose rights had been optioned to veteran
- producer Ray Stark (The Way We Were) for $700,000, evil
- junk-bond genius Michael Milken was well on his way to jail, the
- takeover era was over, and the public backlash against the
- excesses of the '80s had started in a big way. Moreover, the
- catastrophic flop of Brian De Palma's adaptation of Tom Wolfe's
- Bonfire of the Vanities in 1990 had cooled Hollywood on the idea
- of making movies set in Manhattan's financial district. Columbia
- began to shy away from a project that did not seem to have much
- appeal to the Terminator II crowd. When no other studio
- expressed interest, Stark took Barbarians to HBO.
- </p>
- <p> The script by playwright and television writer Larry
- Gelbart (M*A*S*H) focuses on the struggle between the two
- central characters: Johnson, played by James Garner, and Kravis,
- played by Jonathan Pryce, who starred in the Broadway hit
- musical Miss Saigon. People familiar with Wall Street will have
- serious problems with these two pieces of casting because Garner
- doesn't behave much like Johnson and Price doesn't look anything
- like Kravis.
- </p>
- <p> "Johnson is kind of a super maitre d', a guy who really
- knows how to work a room," Gelbart explains. But in the book,
- Burrough and Helyar also portray him as a Machiavellian
- cutthroat who betrayed numerous colleagues on his way to the
- top, a spendthrift who moved the RJR Nabisco headquarters to
- Atlanta--callously firing thousands of employees in the
- process--in part because he didn't like "bucolic"
- Winston-Salem, and a derelict CEO who repeatedly misled his
- shareholders, his employees and his board of directors.
- </p>
- <p> Garner, who has never met Johnson, and who deliberately
- avoided reading the book, plays him as a salty-mouthed
- backslapper who is always quick with a joke and whom everyone
- seems to like. Johnson comes off as a likable gasbag--a rogue
- perhaps, but deep down inside an O.K. guy. Garner is simply too
- appealing to capture Johnson's reptilian qualities.
- </p>
- <p> Kravis doesn't get off so easily. Clearly Pryce, a tall,
- refined, dapper Welshman, bears no physical or cultural
- resemblance to the short, nouveau-riche, noncharismatic Kravis.
- Moreover, the aloof Pryce does not seem like the sort of person
- who would ever threaten to break both of a society columnist's
- kneecaps at a benefit, as Kravis reportedly once did. In fact,
- Pryce does not look like the sort of person who would threaten
- to break even one of a society columnist's kneecaps.
- Nevertheless, his performance works, in part because he is so
- understatedly malevolent, in part because the question of
- Kravis' height (5 ft., 6 in., shoes included) is ultimately
- irrelevant. Pryce says this is the first time in his career he
- has ever played a living person. However, he hastens to point
- out, "I have played characters like him before." And who might
- they be? "Richard III," Pryce responds. "Macbeth."
- </p>
- <p> The other figures portrayed in the film come off at least
- as badly as they do in real life. Peter Riegert is right on
- target as the cocky Shearson honcho Peter Cohen. The
- basset-mugged Fred Dalton Thompson, though a bit jowly for the
- part, is convincing as the charming but ineffectual Robinson,
- who last month was shown the door of troubled American Express.
- </p>
- <p> Joanna Cassidy is perfect as Robinson's
- flack-from-the-inferno wife Linda. (It was her firm that cooked
- up the ingenious idea of sending its calaboose-bound client,
- Michael Milken, to Shea Stadium, chaperoning hundreds of poor
- black children, an incident that is still remembered as one of
- the most cynical, albeit futile, stunts in the sorry history of
- public relations.) Rita Wilson as Kravis' wife, the fashion
- designer Carolyne Roehm, is quite believable in the role of a
- woman whose single indulgence was a daily Oreo. Even the smaller
- parts work quite well, notably Leilani Ferrer as Johnson's
- thirtysomething wife Laurie, originally known to her critics as
- "Cupcake," and then, after Ross finagled her an honorary
- doctorate from some roadside Florida university, as "Dr.
- Cupcake."
- </p>
- <p> What prevents Barbarians from being truly outstanding is
- Garner's miscasting plus Gelbart's reluctance to pull the
- trigger on the conniving Johnson. Example: in one scene, the
- born-to-shop Dr. Cupcake tells Ross a heart-wrenching story
- about her leg waxer's cousin, who was dumped from his job of 18
- years when KKR took over his company. Seeking to illustrate the
- human carnage of leveraged buyouts, she informs hubby that the
- man went home and shot himself. Johnson looks concerned. Here,
- the film is taking real liberties with the truth. This
- conversation did not take place anywhere in Burrough and
- Helyar's book. This conversation did not take place anywhere on
- this planet.
- </p>
-
- </body>
- </article>
- </text>
-
-